
- Economic Stimulus: The
Multiplier Effect
- By Byron A. Ellis-November
17, 2008
Lower energy prices, if
sustained, could provide a tremendous yearly economic stimulus. More than
251 million vehicles are on the road; therefore, if each owner saves $40 per
week on gasoline purchases, total yearly aggregate savings would exceed $522
billion dollars.
Moreover, if we account
for the economic multiplier, lower gasoline prices would contribute over
$1.4 trillion dollars to the U.S. economy. This figure is obtained e by
assuming a marginal propensity to consume of 0.80 and a tax rate of 0.20,
then the multiplier {1/[1 – 0.80(1 – 0.20)} is 2.78. So, lower gasoline
prices would add {$522 billion X 2.78 = $1.4 trillion dollars}.
We’re also seeing signs
of lower food prices, which will create additional consumer savings and,
fuel surcharges should also diminish or become non-existent over time.
The effect over time is
to return the economy to the pre-invasion of Iraq level.
Therefore, it is
important for the new administration to establish processes that will
prevent Middle East instability, as well as the resulting speculation in the
crude oil futures markets.
In times of instability,
traders should not be able to purchase more oil on the commodity futures
market than actually exist in transit and in storage.
Purchasing more oil than
actually exist creates an artificial demand and given a fixed supply, the
result is artificially high prices. The commodity market demand for crude
oil is seldom the real demand, since many of the future crude oil purchases
are not physically delivered.
Some economists argue
that speculators stabilize markets. However, how can crude oil speculators
stabilize the market by destabilizing the economy?
Moreover, it is clear
from history that spikes in crude oil prices preceded the vast majority of
economic contractions since World War II.
Thus, unscrupulous
traders should not be allowed to manipulate crude oil prices; crude oil is
the lifeblood of the world economy.
The damaged induced by
high crude oil prices is clear, if lower crude oil prices will add through
the multiplier effect more than $1.4 trillion dollars to the U.S. national
income. Higher crude oil prices caused national income to contract by the
same amount.
As we have argued
before, higher energy prices adversely affected the budgets of U.S.
consumers. U.S. consumers had to reallocate outlays from housing, food,
entertainment, and other commodities and services to compensate for higher
energy prices.
As a result, marginal
consumers were not able to pay their mortgages. And, as mortgage defaults
increased, it affected the bets made using credit default swap (CDS) where
banks and hedge funds allowed
individuals without securities to buy insurance against securities that they
did not own.
A
CDS is, basically, an unregulated financial
insurance whereby the buyer makes periodic payments to the seller in
exchange for the right to a payoff if there is a default or credit event in
respect of a third party or reference entity.
Thus,
the root cause of the current economic contraction is the spike in crude oil
prices due to Middle East instability. Therefore, lower crude oil prices
will increase consumer spending on items other than energy and provide a
needed stimulus to the economy.
Any
additional stimulus from the new administration should be targeted and
relative small, and limited to the promised middle class tax cuts and public
spending on crumbling infrastructure.
With
lower oil prices, the economy will begin to expand. However, if the new
administration over stimulated the economy, the result would be inflation,
higher interest rates, and another contraction.
[
Home |
Comments |
Search |
Post
]
POST COMMENT